Skip to Content

Shopping For Auto Insurance

TELEPHONE NUMBERS AND WEBSITES OF AUTO INSURERS

The following is a list of toll-free telephone numbers and websites at which interested consumers may contact automobile insurance companies. The companies listed make up 90% of the private passenger automobile insurance marketplace (by premium volume) in New York State. Insurers indicated as "Agents Listed" may be found in a local telephone directory under their direct agencies. Insurers denoted with an asterisk (*) do not offer the ability to obtain a quote or purchase a policy directly through their website.

Information on insurers not listed here may be obtained by contacting licensed insurance agents or brokers.

image of telephone

Company Name Telephone Number Website

A-Central Insurance Co.

800-234-6926

www.nycm.com

Adirondack Insurance Exchange*

800-462-2123

www.ngic.com

Allmerica Financial Alliance Insurance Co.

800-922-8427

www.hanover.com/

Allstate Fire and Casualty Insurance Co.

877-810-2920

www.allstate.com

Allstate Indemnity Co.

877-810-2920

www.allstate.com

Allstate Insurance Co.

877-810-2920

www.allstate.com

Amica Mutual Insurance Co.

800-242-6422

www.amica.com

Amica Property and Casualty

800-242-6422

www.amica.com

Chubb National Insurance Co.*

866-324-8222

www.chubb.com/personal/

Citizens Insurance Co. of America

800-922-8427

www.hanover.com/

Country-Wide Insurance Co.*

800-796-9288

https://ins.cwico.com/public/cwi

Erie Insurance Co.

800-458-0811

www.erieinsurance.com

Esurance Insurance Co.

800-378-7262

www.esurance.com

Esurance Property and Casualty Insurance Co.

800-378-7262

www.esurance.com

Foremost Insurance Co. Grand Rapids Michigan

888-888-0080

www.foremost.com

Foremost Signature Insurance Co.

888-888-0080

www.foremost.com

Garrison Property and Casualty Insurance Co.

800-531-8722

www.usaa.com

GEICO General Insurance Co.

800-841-3000

www.geico.com

GEICO Indemnity Co.

800-841-3000

www.geico.com

Government Employees Insurance Co.

800-841-3000

www.geico.com

Hartford Accident and Indemnity Co.

800-423-6789

www.thehartford.com

Hartford Casualty Insurance Co.

800-423-6789

www.thehartford.com

Hartford Fire Insurance Co.

800-423-6789

www.thehartford.com

Hartford Insurance Co. of the Midwest

800-423-6789

www.thehartford.com

Hartford Underwriters Insurance Co.

800-423-6789

www.thehartford.com

Integon National Insurance Co.

800-462-2123

www.ngic.com

Kemper Independence Insurance Co.*

877-252-7878

www.kemper.com/wps/portal/KemperPreferred/Home

Liberty Mutual Insurance Co.

888-323-4487

www.libertymutual.com

LM General Insurance Co.

888-323-4487

www.libertymutual.com

MAPFRE Insurance Co. of New York

855-627-3738

www.mapfreinsurance.com

Massachusetts Bay Insurance Co.

800-922-8427

www.hanover.com/

Mercury Casualty Co.

800-503-3724

www.mercuryinsurance.com

Metropolitan Casualty Insurance Co.

844-569-3607

www.metlife.com

Metropolitan Group Property & Casualty Insurance Co.

844-569-3607

www.metlife.com

Mid Century Insurance Co.

800-493-4917

www.farmers.com

National General Assurance Co.

800-462-2123

www.ngic.com

National General Insurance Co.

800-462-2123

www.ngic.com

National General Insurance Online, Inc.

800-462-2123

www.ngic.com

Nationwide Affinity Insurance Co. of America*

877-669-6877

www.nationwide.com

Nationwide Mutual Insurance Co.*

877-669-6877

www.nationwide.com

New York Central Mutual Fire Ins Co.

800-234-6926

www.nycm.com

Preferred Mutual Insurance Co.*

800-333-7642

www.preferredmutual.com

Progressive Advanced Ins Co.

800-776-4743

www.progressive.com

Progressive Casualty Ins Co.

800-776-4743

www.progressive.com

Progressive Max Ins Co.

800-776-4743

www.progressive.com

Progressive Specialty Ins Co.

800-776-4743

www.progressive.com

Property and Casualty Insurance Co. of Hartford

800-423-6789

www.thehartford.com

Republic Franklin Insurance Co.

800-598-8422

www.uticanational.com

Sentinel Insurance Co., Ltd

800-423-6789

www.thehartford.com

State Farm Fire and Casualty Co.

Agents Listed

www.statefarm.com

State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Co.

Agents Listed

www.statefarm.com

The Hanover Insurance Co.*

800-922-8427

www.hanover.com

Travelers Personal Insurance Co.

866-522-1338

www.travelers.com

Travelers Personal Security Insurance Co.

866-522-1338

www.travelers.com

Trumbull Insurance Co.

800-423-6789

www.thehartford.com

Twin City Fire Insurance Co.

800-423-6789

www.thehartford.com

United Services Automobile Association

800-531-8722

www.usaa.com

USAA Casualty Insurance Co.

800-531-8722

www.usaa.com

USAA General Indemnity Co.

800-531-8722

www.usaa.com

Utica Mutual Insurance Co.*

800-598-8422

www.uticanational.com

Utica National Ins. Co of Texas*

800-598-8422

www.uticanational.com

Shopping for Auto Insurance |Consumers - Insurance Products | Insurers - Property Insurance

Updated 04/16/2018

Department of Financial Services

CONNECT WITH US

DFS Facebook page

Follow NYDFS on Twitter

REGISTER TO VOTE

Sign up online or download and mail in your application.